This site is part of the superjer.com network

Buffy Reviews & Media by Mikejer
home
reviews
podcast
articles
links
discussion


CHECKPOINT (5x12)

A review by Mikelangelo "MikeJer" Marinaro

Writer(s): Jane Espenson and Douglas Petrie
Director: Nick Marck
- Quick Links

- Review

This is a wonderfully pleasant episode and is Buffy's first serious take on the subject of power, which of course is a major theme of S7. Aside from a couple small isssues, this is solid material that both offers a bit to think about as well as being very entertaining. Even with major appearances from the Watcher's Council and Glory, "Checkpoint" stays focused on Buffy and how she takes another fine step into adulthood while discovering more about her power as a Slayer which, of course, is a big theme of the season. I really love how she's portrayed as still being childish in many ways ("They're gonna expect me to... to be like a Slayer and, and know stuff, but I'm just me and I don't know anything, and they're gonna go away, and they're not gonna tell me how to fight Glory, and I'm not gonna be able to protect Dawn.") but when push comes to shove she steps up on her own and acts as an adult that is extremely formiddable and, dare I say, powerful ("I have it. They don't. This bothers them.").

As Buffy will come to fully realize in S7, "It's about power. Who's got it. Who knows how to use it" (Lessons [7x01]). "Checkpoint" begins the extent of that knowledge and gets Buffy to begin that level of understanding in some clever ways. Throughout the episode we're shown different shades of how power can be used to accomplish things. One side of the coin is the Watchers Council who, as Buffy finds out thanks to Giles, use their political power to get things done the way they want it done. They storm in with their supreme cockiness, shoe away customers, and make their authority known. The review is obviously very reminiscent of the test in Helpless (3x12). The other side of the coin is Glory, who uses her sheer physical power to force what she wants, displaying extreme cockiness in her power over "Mousey." Both of these entities attempt to use their respective powers to threaten Buffy into getting what they want. They're also both accustomed to getting what they want.

At first the intimidation from both sides is quite effective against Buffy. The Council has her doubting her ability to impress them in the odd way they want things done, and Glory has Buffy just plain scared--enough to drop her mom and sister off at Spike's crypt, a huge change in their relationship which Spike immediately points out and a bit later I will too. After the Knights come into the picture as well, it pushes Buffy to acknowledge something that just never occurred to her before: she actually has power over them. If she didn't, they wouldn't even need to use their powers. So Buffy fights back which culminates in a rousing conclusion in which she utterly defies the Council, and then flips the coin back onto them. There is more writing excellence at work here.

Some specific examples of these displays of power include Glory telling Buffy, "If I wanted to fight, you could tell with the being dead already" along with Quentin's speech about Buffy's 'place.' Glory is verbally expressing her power over Buffy while Quentin essentially tells Buffy that she's disposable but the Council always remains--they have the power. It's obvious here how Giles feels. He's more attached to Buffy now that he's ever been, which makes sense based on how close they've been all season due to the training and the shared secret about Dawn. He really sticks up for her until the council speaks of what they're capable of doing. In Helpless (3x12) Giles ultimately decided to go against the Council's test, standing up for Buffy even though it costed him his job. The Council also recognizes his attachment to Buffy and uses that piece of information to threaten Buffy into cooperating. Buffy tells the Watchers "you don't have that kind of power." They are quick to respond, "we do, and a great deal more." In the training room Buffy, like usual, has to do things her own way so she fails the Council's test. The test, however, has no practical purpose, hence Giles' comment, "I've trained her to win."

On an entertainingly different note I was very entertained by Buffy's school endeavors. Yawning in class and tapping her pencil out of boredom. This just reminds me of how glad I am I'm done with the game that is academia. Also amusing is Buffy suggesting that Rasputin might have been a vampire or a demon (haha). That evening we see Buffy taking out her academic frustrations on the demon world, which is very happily lovely, classic Buffy. The "interviews" were all also extremely entertaining. Everyone is trying way too hard to not make Buffy look bad. I particularly enjoyed Lydia getting all flustered over meeting Spike in person.

While talking about Spike, it's important to recognize some important signs that pop up here. Buffy tells Spike she doesn't need a boyfriend. Which, by the way, good for her! But Spike doesn't quit that easily and snipes back, "don't need, or can't keep." He says, "Maybe that's your problem, maybe you push 'em away. Or is it the other? Maybe you cling too much. Or maybe... your beauty's fading. The stress of slaying, aging you prematurely. Things not as high, not as firm ... Or maybe you just don't hold their interest." All of Spike's rambling does eventually get Buffy thinking. After her encounter with Glory, Buffy still goes to Spike to protect Joyce and Dawn, even after their earlier oral jabs. Spike's response is hilarious, "well there's a boatload of manly responsibility flying out of nowhere." Putting aside the amusement, this also proves that Spike is just as much aware of how much trust Buffy's putting in him as we, the audience, are. This marks an important change in the relationship between Buffy and Spike. Despite her apparent disgust of him, when it comes down to it she does now trust him with the things that matter most to her, and that says a lot.

On the pure plot front not much happens in this episode, although we do get the Knights of Byzantium. The Knights add an extra layer to the season's plot arc, but unfortunately the writers neglected to use them until Spiral (5x20) which, honestly, was way too little, way too late. Their use here, though, is mysterious and effective in adding yet another thing Buffy has to worry about.

After all Buffy's been through by the end of the episode, she lays it on the Watchers and proves to them that she has the power that matters. Here's the goods: "You guys didn't come all the way from England to determine whether or not I was good enough to be let back in. You came to beg me to let you back in. To give your jobs, your lives some semblance of meaning ... You're Watchers. Without a Slayer, you're pretty much just watchin' Masterpiece Theater. You can't stop Glory. You can't do anything with the information you have except maybe publish it in the Everyone Thinks We're Insane-O's Home Journal. So here's how it's gonna work. You're gonna tell me everything you know. Then you're gonna go away. You'll contact me if and when you have any further information about Glory." After Quentin agrees to Buffy terms, she then sits down at Quentin's level and is ready to talk with him. This initiative shows great growth in Buffy's character and ability as a leader capable of handling things completely on her own.

To sum matters up, I really enjoyed "Checkpoint" and found that is has quite a bit of lasting value. It's mix of humor and challenging character growth is a cut above the rest, which isn't something I say lightly when it comes to episodes of this show. Aside from a couple minor issues and the fact that even though this episode is important, it really doesn't feel all that important, "Checkpoint" nails all the right chords.


- Minor Pros/Cons (+/-)
+  Buffy getting freaked out over the news of the Council visiting.
+  Ben shutting Jinx and Glory down.
+  Glory wants Ben to get the key for her. She still doesn't want to have to do it herself. For the first time since No Place Like Home (5x05) we see her get fed up with waiting and take some action.
+  Spike and Joyce sharing some more amusing moments together. Wonderful!
+  Buffy's confident Quentin will tell her that Glory is something she's familiar with. QUENTIN: "She's a god." BUFFY: "Oh."
-  What's with Buffy always having to stand up in class? I never stood up on the rare occasion I'd offer an answer.
-  Why do the Watchers even do all this crazy shit? Unfortunately the answers to that question are never explored in a meaningful way.

- Quotes
GILES:   They're probably already on their way. Our old friend Quentin Travers is ... heading up the delegation.
BUFFY:   They put me through that test, and it almost killed me. And then, when I was Faith, they almost killed me again. Honestly, I really can't handle almost being killed right now.

GLORY:   Sunnydale's got too many demons and not enough retail outlets.

NIGEL:   Magic Box shoppers! We're going to have to ask you to leave. The store is, uh, closing early today.
PHILIP:   Terribly sorry for the inconvenience.
ANYA:   Hey! Giles, what are they doing? Customers! Please bring your money back!

TRAVERS:   Miss, excuse me, you uh, you work here?
ANYA:   Yes I do. Ever since I moved here from southeastern Indiana, where I was raised by both a mother and a father.

PROFESSOR:   I can assure you there is near consensus in the academic community regarding the death of Rasputin.
BUFFY:   There was also near consensus about Columbus, you know, until someone asked the Vikings what they were up to in the 1400s, and they're like, "discovering this America-shaped continent."

BUFFY:   I didn't need you. I never need you, Spike.
SPIKE:   Oh, I get it. (follows) You just don't like who did the rescuin', that's all. Wishin' I was your boyfriend what's-his-face. Oh wait, he's run off.

GILES:   I should have set you loose on them, that's what I should have done.
BUFFY:   Giles, that Travers guy is like sixty. I can't hit him. Can I?

PHILIP:   I think she just broke my rib.
BUFFY:   I didn't mean to! Um, you know, I, I can do better. I think I might be getting this, like, inner ear thing, and so maybe, maybe if I got a note, I, I could try again.

BUFFY:   I need your help.
SPIKE:   Great. I need your cash.
BUFFY:   I'm serious. You have to look after them.
SPIKE:   Well, that's a boatload of manly responsibility to come flying out of nowhere. What's the matter, Slayer? You're not feeling a hundred percent?
BUFFY:   (frowns) No.
SPIKE:   (frowns) They didn't put a chip in your head, did they?
BUFFY:   No!
SPIKE:   Be funny if they did.

WATCHER2:   I, uh, I ... don't want a sword thrown at me, but, but, civilians, I - we're talking about children.
BUFFY:   We're talking about two very powerful witches and a thousand-year-old ex-demon.
ANYA:   Willow's a demon!?

-
Score
90 /100
A-
Everything that an 'A' possesses, but with either a few more mistakes or slightly less power. Generally represents great episodes that are a tiny bit rough around the edges.

- Screencaps




- Comments (22)

1.cayayofm  Dec 22 2006
A very nice review, it has been a while. I very much agree. The episode does not do a lot for the plot, but there are a few interesting things going on. One of the things that I most agree is with the Knights of Byzantium point. They are nicely introduced here, to be completly forgotten until 'Spiral', in wich by then they end up looking just like a plot device for the episode, since they were never explored.

Hope to see reviews more often. Also agree that you shoukldwait until you finish with the show and later review season 8.

2.Rick  Dec 22 2006
Oddly enough, I was always confused about that scene in which Buffy fights Phillip; did she impress or disappoint Quentin. Yes the dummy got killed very quickly which = bad. But remember the lecture about how "getting the best of Phillip will take....and strenght and STAMINA will win the race." Well, Buffy, once doing things her way, dispatched of him effortlessly. To make matters worse, Quentin's "That's quite alright, I don't think we need to see any more physical tests" is also ambiguous (meaning "you clearly suck" or "obviously you're not weak.") Please help me decide. I still cant tell!!!

3.Rick  Dec 22 2006
Also she did break his ribs.

4.Dingdongalistic  Dec 23 2006

- QUOTE -
On the pure plot front not much happens in this episode, although we do get the Knights of Byzantium. The Knights add an extra layer to the season's plot arc, but unfortunately the writers neglected to use them until Spiral (5x20).
I agree that they were perhaps a layer too much, and neglected for that reason, but I still think when it came to Spiral they were effective in their purpose, to show what a deadly situation Buffy had got into. They also brought up seriously interesting moral ideas into the episode, so although I'd say they were too little, they weren't too late.

5.mikejer  Dec 23 2006
A couple lines in particular aside, I felt the Knights in "Spiral" came across as obscenely hokey and unrealistic. That's one of my major problems with the episode. I'll, of course, address this in detail in my upcoming review.

Btw, the comment system should still be working just fine. I did a test comment and it went through perfectly. I'd suggest giving it another try. If you still have an issue, let me know.

6.Fallen  Dec 23 2006
I dunno, I think they sold it as fanatics pretty well. Few lines were a bit bleh, but none that really made them stand out as unrealistic.

7.mikejer  Dec 24 2006
Riding horses on a California highway chasing after a winnebago? Umm....remotely believeable? I say not. And when that one dying knight reaches his hand out saying "The Beaast...argh!" it's just too much for me. I'd thought BtVS was past that level of bad corniness. The episode has its merit, particularly in some subtle but important character interaction, but overall it left me fairly unimpressed.

8.Dingdongalistic  Dec 24 2006
Can you honestly say a lot of what Buffy does is remotely believable? It's the characterisation that's realistic, not the plots. The scene on the highway was fantastic, and epitomised how Buffy could work so well contrasting the ridiculous with the everyday - the Knights are known fanatics, and seem to cling to tradition, but that doesn't stop them being a dangerous force. Half the villains in season five don't exactly move with the times. The only thing which is a little unrealistic was for Buffy to get the Winnebago in the first place, but I'd attribute this to panicked reasoning. It would have been far more sensible for them to have split up into two cars.

And the Knight's line? Sure, it wasn't brilliant, but in all honesty it was far more subtle than you were putting it. He didn't go "argh", or at least not audible. He might have grunted. But if you have a problem with slightly unrefined lines like this then I'm surprised you don't have a problem with Glory - she spouts twice as corny dialogue half the time.

As for character interaction, apart from the great action scenes Spiral excells in them. The ideas running through it are subtle, but they are impressive, and the scenes with Ben are excellent, in my opinion.

9.mikejer  Dec 24 2006
The Winnebago was just over the top imo. As I mentioned in my previous post, the ep does have its merits, so I'm not trying to completely trash it. Overall, though, I wasn't particularly thrilled with it, at least from the perspective of not looking at it extremely closely, review-wise.

10.Dingdongalistic  Dec 24 2006
"Oddly enough, I was always confused about that scene in which Buffy fights Phillip; did she impress or disappoint Quentin. Yes the dummy got killed very quickly which = bad. But remember the lecture about how "getting the best of Phillip will take....and strenght and STAMINA will win the race." Well, Buffy, once doing things her way, dispatched of him effortlessly. To make matters worse, Quentin's "That's quite alright, I don't think we need to see any more physical tests" is also ambiguous (meaning "you clearly suck" or "obviously you're not weak.") Please help me decide. I still cant tell!!!"

Probably both - knowing Travers, he probaby hadn't made his mind up yet.

11.Dingdongalistic  Dec 24 2006

- QUOTE -
On the pure plot front not much happens in this episode, although we do get the Knights of Byzantium. The Knights add an extra layer to the season's plot arc, but unfortunately the writers neglected to use them until Spiral (5x20).
I agree that they were perhaps a layer too much, and neglected for that reason, but I still think when it came to Spiral they were effective in their purpose, to show what a deadly situation Buffy had got into. They also brought up seriously interesting moral ideas into the episode, so although I'd say they were too little, they weren't too late.

12.bookworm  Dec 26 2006
There are certain storylines, where I know how I react, no matter what. At "Innocence" I'm close to tears (AKA crying) from "I thought you were a pro" until Buffy's dream as I'm in the break-up scene of "The Prom", when Buffy tells Willow "I can't breathe". The end of Becoming and The Gift keep me breathless, as does the entire episode of "The Body". When Buffy tells Giles, what happened in "Two To Go" I laugh as hard as does Giles. I'm screaming of joy at Giles's entry in "Villains".

And the sword fight on the Winnebago makes me pee my pants. I get excited just thinking about it. It's my top-fight scene of the Buffyverse.

Plus: "You know, it's your fault for saying that."

13.Tranquillity  Feb 19 2007
On the DVD you can read the script for this episode and unfortunaltly some very funny dialogue had to be cut out. Spike and Buffy's conversation when she drops off Joyce and Dawn is longer but the best bit is the extended dialogue between Lydia and Spike in his crypt - what a shame it didn't make the final cut! well worth reading.LibMax

14.LibMax  Jul 26 2007
Rick regarding the Phillip battle and MikeJer regarding why the Watchers do all this crazy shit: I think you may have missed some of the point about Buffy's "examination," namely that it's BS. They weren't really testing her at all - they were just putting her on the defensive, trying to make her feel small and stupid so she'd let them control her.

The Phillip-dummy fight is a perfect case in point. Notice how unrealistic and needlessly complicated it is. That way, even if she defeats Phillip handily without taking out the dummy in the process, she can still "fail" by not executing the right maneuvers in the right order (through not understanding Japanese). If you want to set up a combat test which Buffy is guaranteed to fail, can you think of a better way to do it?

15.Austin  Aug 29 2007

- QUOTE -
Despite her apparent disgust of him, when it comes down to it she does now trust him with the things that matter most to her, and that says a lot.
Since when can she trust him? Since he tried to get his chip out and bite her or since doing his best to ruin her and Riley's relationship and then rubbing it in her face?

Anyways, I love this ep, she's got the coucil in check and she manages to make the entire gang proud of her and the part they play in it. Definiately A material :)

16.gabrielleabelle  Nov 12 2007
Love the ep. I love the ending, especially, with Buffy standing up to the Council.

I tend to think that Buffy left her mom and Dawn with Spike out of necessity. He IS the strongest person she knows. Plus, he's chipped so she knows he can't hurt them. Also, she knows that HE knows that she'll stake him if anything happens to them. Thankfully, Spike rises to the occasion with only a few snide remarks.

17.gabrielleabelle  Nov 12 2007
Oh, another thing. Professors in the Buffyverse seem quite mean. I've never ever seen a professor act like that towards a student. A similar thing happened in The Freshman that threw me for a loop. Not too mention the whole Prof Walsh being an evil scientist thing. I think the writers had some college issues.

18.buffyholic  Nov 26 2007
This is definitively A plus material. This is an amazing episode and my favorite scene of all is when Buffy stands up to the Council. Really amazing.

19.Plain Simple  Feb 26 2008
^And the look of pride on Giles' face during that scene is wonderful.

20.Toby  Jul 29 2008
I don't know what american university is like but here in Australia, lecturers would NEVER belittle their students - no matter how rash their theories or decisions were.

I don't know if Joss went to University or even if American universities are much more brutal in the teaching sense than they are here (kinda mellow here, lecturers and tutors treat you more like equals) but in the entire series of Buffy, THIS is the one thing that pisses me off the most.

Apart form that this episode is amusing, entertaining but certainly contains one of my favourite Buffy moments when she stands up to the Watcher's Council and pretty much says "This is how it's going to be..." and lays down the law! I feel like cheering with the rest of the Scoobies at the end of her speech.

Great review again.

21.Tony  Aug 31 2008
Willow's a demon!?

22.bigmoneygrip  Nov 23 2008
Spike and Joyce both "Passions" fans - love it!

Nice continuity - Xander's wrist still bandaged

Buffy bitch slapping the council, then bitch slapping them again about Xander



- Post a Comment
Name


(copy your comment in case of failure!)

Security Code
Security Code


Copyright © 2000-2008 SuperJer.com. All rights reserved.